Three Americans (created by Erica Rosner, Ruby Schneider, and Eddie Peach-Righton) revisits the Kelly Nolan case through a blend of careful reporting and personal reflection, tracing the events of her disappearance alongside the investigation and the public speculation that followed. Drawing from local news coverage and community discussions, this student podcast not only retells the case but also reflects on its lasting impact—asking what it means to live with its proximity and what it reveals about safety, memory, and the stories we continue to piece together.